Can't you guys agree to watch it together in your separate locations? I used to simul-watch stuff with my long distance bf -- we would both watch stuff at the same time and chat online while we were watching. Or you could just agree to watch on the same day, if that's too hard to manage.

I agree, I couldn't BELIEVE Buffy wasn't on your list. So much smarter and wittier than the title would lead you to believe! It's one of the best-written shows I've ever watched.